Maryland v. The People's Republic of China
July 03, 2008
It began as an effort to protect the children of Maryland from unsafe toys. Now, thanks to a disgruntled Chinese government and WTO, Del. James Hubbard’s (D-Prince George's County) proposed legislation in the Maryland General Assembly on potentially harmful chemicals has entered the ranks of “barriers” to international trade.
As you may remember, last year saw a slew of recalled Chinese toys, which were found to contain dangerously high levels of lead. Hubbard, dissatisfied with the Bush administration’s response, proposed a bill that would allow Maryland to monitor its own toys. The bill, which will clear Maryland store shelves of dangerous toys, did more than raise international eyebrows. From a recent article in the Washington Post, here’s how it went down:
The Office of the U.S. Trade Representative alerted the Chinese government, which sent a letter from Beijing to protest the bill as a barrier to trade. Lawmakers in Annapolis were unfazed and passed the bill, which takes effect next month.
Then came a four-page missive from the World Trade Organization's Committee on Technical Barriers to Trade -- in English and Chinese -- opposing another of Hubbard's bills, to ban a chemical compound called bisphenol A that is central to the plastics industry. Manufacturers in the United States and China use the compound in baby bottles and other products. With testimony on both sides, the bill did not pass out of a House committee.
The Chinese said there is "no specific scientific evidence" proving that products containing bisphenol A are hazardous to children.
Hubbard said he believes both complaints were prompted by lobbyists for the chemical industry, here in Washington.
"I truly feel the [chemical] industry and the toy industry are running to China and saying, 'You ought to oppose these bills, and if you don't you'll lose out on product sales in America,'" he said.
The WTO’s signature 'trade until proven deadly'
threat justification was successful, and the bill didn’t make it out of a House committee. In an interview on the Kojo Nnamdi Show on Monday, Hubbard expressed his consternation: "This was a public health issue, not a trade issue."
In the past, international trade rules have stretched an intervening hand into state legislatures on a number of important issues, including health-related environmental regulations. Yet the WTO, not to mention Chinese government's attempts to preemptively intervene in a state's legislative process is taking their vested interest to another level.
Concerned that similar legislation would receive such undesired attention in Maine, the state's Citizen Trade Policy Commission issued a letter to the USTR which received this response. Hardly reassuring, their explanation is that the WTO notification system which "normally calls for us to notify proposed agency regulations" had "inadvertly included certain state legislative proposals." They assure it will not happen again in the future.
As states increasingly feel the yoke of international trade agreements in which they have had virtually no say, legislators from around the country are seeking new ways to work together to improve the process of state-federal consultation when it comes to trade policy-making.
Special thanks to Isaac Raisner for his contribution to this post.
Hi! My name is Cyndi, and I'm an intern for an upcoming movie called "Battle in Seattle." I came across your blog on fair trade, and I've read through many posts and thoroughly enjoy it. Thank you for taking the time to get information about fair trade out! Battle in Seattle is about the 1999 World Trade Organization protests in Seattle. Over 40,000 people gathered in the streets to stop the WTO talks that were supposed to go on. The film discusses these issues by intertwining real documentary footage of the protests with fictional storylines about individual characters. I got to see a screening a few nights ago, and the film is amazing. The protesters were against free trade (primarily), and were fighting for more human rights around the world, fair wages, etc. Fair trade is at the heart of this film. It's starring Charlize Theron, Woody Harrelson, Channing Tatum, Michelle Rodriguez, etc - so it's got an amazing A-list cast, but it's a completely independent film. We're starting a grassroots effort at getting information about both about the film and the causes the film represents to the public, trying to generate support. If you would be interested in talking about the film at all on your site, that would be amazing and so appreciated. I have access to some photos and a lot of reference information for the issues. My email is email@example.com. I'm so looking forward to hearing from you! Thanks for reading this!
Posted by: Cyndi | July 03, 2008 at 04:00 PM
It is being said that I, Mark J. Lerner, am working in China to stop these tricky communist thugs and lackies of financial growth from poisoning our beautiful American children with cheap lead paint and dangerous products.
It is said that I am doing this by secretly working with young sex workers in China and passing diseases into the Chinese culture!
Others say that I am hiding money in China from the IRS.
All of these things are bald-faced lies!
Posted by: Mark J Lerner | September 19, 2008 at 02:36 AM
American consumers buy more than 1.7 billion toys each year, according to an
estimate from the Toy Manufacturers Association of America. In general, most toys on the market today are safe. But, injuries still occur in spite of tough government regulations and toy makers' efforts to test products.
Posted by: sarah | November 21, 2008 at 04:25 AM
I came across your blog on fair trade, and I've read through many posts and thoroughly enjoy it. Thank you for taking the time to get information about fair trade out!
Posted by: x-ray fluorescence | January 12, 2009 at 01:28 AM
airfare travel airfare travel [url=http://www.cam.cornell.edu/~rclewley/cgi-bin/moin.cgi/GoodPractice?action=AttachFile&do=get&target=43]ski vacations[/url] discount air fares discount minute airfares last minute airline [url=http://www.cam.cornell.edu/~rclewley/cgi-bin/moin.cgi/GoodPractice?action=AttachFile&do=get&target=33]flight tracker[/url] flight ticket cheap flight airfare com airfare deal airfare deals [url=http://www.cam
Posted by: vordWarFedlyWhobbouh | March 26, 2009 at 10:57 AM