• TheWatchdogBlog.org is published by Public Citizen's Congress Watch. We work to ensure that Congress represents citizens by exposing the harmful impact of money in politics and fighting for an improved democracy. We also champion consumer interests before the U.S. Congress and seek to preserve citizen access to the courts to redress corporate harm and negligence.

Our Mascot

  • Our mascot, Brandice
Statement of Policies

« The Solution to the Money Problem Introduced | Main | $28,500 per Couple... »

The Justice Department Massacre Unravels

Yesterday, the Senate put an end to a dangerous political game.  By a vote of 94 to 2, it passed S. 214, which ensures U.S. Attorneys are independent of political manipulation.  The legislation brings back the checks and balances of prior law so that an Administration no longer will be able to do an end-run around Senate confirmation by making an interim appointment.  As we are learning, Attorney General Alberto Gonzales, working hand-in-glove with the White House - think Karl Rove – fired eight federal prosecutors based on apparent political considerations including, at least in some instances, possibly to protect Republican wrongdoers from prosecution, as I discussed in an earlier opinion piece. 

Before this Administration came to power, politicizing federal prosecutors would have been unthinkable.  It also would have been of little political advantage to make a partisan interim appointment because that was time-limited, and the Senate would not confirm a 4-year appointment if the person did not exhibit the highest level of independence and integrity.  It was for this reason that, at the urging of the Administration, Republicans jammed through the little-noticed provision as part of last year’s renewal of the PATRIOT Act.  This revision gave the Attorney General the authority to replace fired prosecutors with interim appointments indefinitely, thereby allowing replacements to be chosen based on loyalty to Bush - not the Constitution - and shielded from exposure to Senate confirmation for the remainder of the Administration’s term.  Don’t be fooled when Bush says he did nothing wrong because the prosecutors serve at his pleasure.  That’s a big red herring.

We now know this cynical political game started back in 2005 when political advisers in the White House wanted to fire U.S. Attorneys that weren’t sufficiently loyal to Bush.  In a May 11th 2006 e-mail from Attorney General Gonzales’s chief of staff, Kyle Sampson (who himself has had to resign), to a Deputy White House Counsel, Sampson refers to “the real problem we have right now with Carol Lam that leads me to conclude we should have somebody ready to be nominated…the day her 4-year term expires.”  Carol Lam was the outstanding U.S. Attorney in San Diego, and former judge who successfully prosecuted Congressman Randy “Duke” Cunningham (R-Calif.) for bribery.  For this Administration, the “real” problem with Lam was that she was prosecuting political corruption in Republican ranks.  It’s no accident that Sampson’s May 11th e-mail was written the same day the Los Angeles Times reported an on-going probe of Jerry Lewis (R-Calif.), the then Chairman of the all-powerful House Appropriations Committee, which flowed from the Cunningham corruption case.

This Administration is only loyal to itself, not to the nation or to the Constitution.  In its quest for ever-more power for the sake of power, it has carelessly thrown overboard independent-minded prosecutors with barely a second thought, lied and concealed when the game was exposed and, worst of all, subjected these public servants to public humiliation.  At least we can be proud that these eight U. S. Attorneys stood up, spoke out, and pushed back.  They too have sent a clear and powerful message - don't politicize prosecutors – and we have heard it.  So has Congress.  A House subcommittee just authorized subpoenas for Karl Rove and former White House adviser Harriet Miers.          


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The Justice Department Massacre Unravels:


Charles Barrett

i"m proud of the work these US attorneys have done and hope that the administration will be brought to justice for their interference in these investigations. IMPEACH BUSH AND CHENEY!

Betty & Martin Ellyn

Why can't the government, actually Congress, hire computer experts to remove the missing emails regarding the firing of the States Attorneys from Karl Rove's etc. hard drives.


Why can't Congress hire computer experts to recover the missing emails concerning the firing of the 8 States Attorneys from the hard drives of Karl Rove and the other White House Employees involved?


I’d like someone to tell me, please, what authority the Senate and/or House Reps have to fire the Attorney General? It seems to me, that one of two things has happened, the US attorney general, who makes the laws for the rest of the people is covering up for the President and his people, - or this man is just to stupid to be the Attorney General for the People of the United States. The man can’t remember, can’t recall, or cant say, either way, don’t we have the right to FIRE incompetent people anymore?

Is is just my opinion, or does anyone agree with me that someone that incompetent just can't represent anyone from the United States anywhere? Can't we fire this guy and appoint a replacement if one is so desperately needed.

And if we had to replace - can't we appoint a suitable candidate, given the president's history of hiring qualified and experienced candidates thus far?

The comments to this entry are closed.